I want to start a conversation. It may not work, but I want to try.
Let me begin by defining who I mean by 'contemporary church.' I do not mean Christians who sing praise choruses or who don't wear suits to church. That's how the contemporary church movement started, but it has moved beyond that. Perhaps a clearer term would be 'Hyper-Contemporary,' but I doubt you will appreciate that, so I'll stick with the other. By 'contemporary,' I mean Christians who design their church services around the
unchurched in the community, Christians who embrace the postmodern culture, Christians who want their services to be known for their creativity and entertainment appeal, Christians who prefer catchy "How-To" sermons. The list could go on, but you probably get the picture.
I honestly desire to talk with you about things. I've tried to comment on some of your blogs, but my comments never make it through the screening process. So I invite you to my blog, hoping that you will hear my desire to respectfully discuss some issues.
Let me begin by pointing out two good things I see in your efforts. First, you are concerned about the lost, and I praise God for that. One of the many problems with the 'traditional church' is that we (I'll place myself in that category for now) have become so focused on the church organization that we've lost sight of the world around us. I admit it. We've dropped the ball on reaching out, and I would love to see our congregations have the enthusiasm about evangelism that your congregations have. Second, you desire to engage the culture. Scroll through my blog and you'll see that I, too, attempt to engage the culture. Though we go about it differently, we're on the same page here. This current culture is
unchurched, skeptical, and entertainment-driven. The traditional church seems blind to this. As Christians, we must address it in some way, and I'm grateful to our Lord that you have that desire.
But I'm concerned. Some days I get angry at what you guys do. Other days I'm shocked and discouraged by what you guys do. Please hear me out. Allow me to list three concerns:
1) Man-Centered Worship vs. God-Centered Worship = I'm using the term 'man-centered' to mean that the focus is on the desires and needs of people. You
unapologetically center your worship around the
unchurched visitors who may attend. People want rock concert style music, so you offer it. People want fun and exciting things for their kids, so you offer it. People want coffee and doughnuts, so you offer it. People want entertainment, so you offer it. The results? People come to church... by the thousands! But is this growth good growth? And is what you offer on Sunday mornings or afternoons actually worship?
I freely admit that I'm old-school when it comes to this stuff. I'm 25 and I like hymns... I know; I'm weird. But this goes beyond the question of preference to the question of rightness. This isn't a question of practicality (does it work?); it's a question of '
biblicality' (does God's Word accept this?). No, the Bible doesn't commend or condemn rock music and doughnuts, but the purpose of these things is to please people. Scripture never commands us to do that. Rather, we're told to please God, even if it offends people at times. I firmly believe that man-centered worship is self-idolatry, placing what appeals to us or the
unchurched above what honors God.
2) Man-Centered Preaching vs. God-Centered Preaching = This same problem carries itself into the preaching at your churches it seems. You preach to entertain and to meet felt needs. "People don't care about doctrine and theology, they just want to make their marriage work," you may say. But the Bible is oh so clear on this. First Corinthians 2:1-5 tells us that preaching isn't to be entertaining and impressive. First Thessalonians 2:1-12 addresses the same issue by Paul saying, "We speak, not to please man, but to please God who tests our hearts." Our sermons should not be man-centered. They should be God-centered. They should speak of a Holy God, a sinful humanity, a sinless Christ, and a necessary
response. That is the Gospel. That is a person's deepest need, and to give them anything other than this is cheating them and disobeying God.
3) Cultural Engaging vs. Cultural Embracing = Lastly, I'm concerned with the way your churches handle the culture. I'm all for engaging culture and creating culture, but that isn't what I see in your churches. I see you embracing the culture. You may not see the problem with this, so let me explain what I mean.
Romans 1:18-32 clearly describes our modern culture. Here are just a few excerpts: "
For their women exchanged natural relations for those that are contrary to nature; and the men likewise gave up natural relations with women and were consumed with passion for one another." "
They are full of envy, murder, strife..." "
They are... disobedient to parents, foolish, faithless, heartless..." That is us! That is our culture. And God says twice in this passage that He "gave them up." John MacArthur, a pastor from
Los Angeles, rightly considers this culture to be abandoned by God. Yet, this very same culture is the culture that contemporary Christians whole-heartedly embrace. Guys, I just don't get it. How can you title your sermons after Girls Gone Wild and Desperate Housewives? How can you host a Super Sexy Sunday? You are embracing a culture that is abandoned by God. Can you please explain why? Can you please share how you think using wickedness is honoring to the Lord?
I realize that you guys get a lot of criticism. That's not my desire here. I have sincere problems that need sincere answers. I'm open to critiques. I'm curious for answers. I'm honestly concerned. Let the conversation begin!
For the Gospel,
Josh